I had Progressive Insurance on two bikes a DR650 and a FJR1300 registered in western NC back around 2007, plus a big toy hauler 5th wheel. After about 3 years they jumped the policy cost on the two bikes up over $1,000, no claim, no tickets, nada. So I went back to Allstate with a family discount and it was much cheaper even when I registered in Atlanta, GA.
Allstate was horrible to deal with though, the body shop said it was normal. They fought everything. I wanted OEM parts on the body work. Not some thin flimsy knock off parts. Eventually I got the truck fixed kinda correctly, but it was a fight. Allstate was horrible when my parents had home damage, they wouldn't fix the house after water damage. Almost had to take them to court, but the insurance commisioner complaint worked and they covered the carpet finally. Switched to Alpha!
Alpha has been okay on the house claims and they covered my truck when a tree fell on it. We had about $60,000 in claims one year and it was slow but they eventually made us whole. But they went way up on the rates state wide, so we went to Safeco a few years ago.
SafeCo has been reasonable rate wise here in Alabama, the claims process has been fine too. No issues really and we went through a major claim after tornado damage. We have multiple things with SafeCo now, never had a motorcycle claim though. They do have medical coverage on bikes, I like having that coverage with the little deductible. The old DL1000 is around $220 per year, I think that's cheap with the medical coverage.
Rural Alabama is actually a little more than the Atlanta metro. They say there is more auto and bike theft in rural Alabama, go figure. But, I can recommend SafeCo here in the SE US, best experience with an insurance company by far. They have gone up on the rates, but its understandable with the storms lately. The claims process was good on the house, we lost the roof to straight line winds. No auto or bike claims though Safeco, hopefully won't have any!