I think it will vary. And others rear end will not be the same as yours. I'd say get one and try it, if you are not happy, get the other. Start with cheaper. Seat is a very personal thing and it takes multiple tries to sort out "just right" for some.
I have a Beadrider, yes. I love it for shorter rides (~300 miles) and love it for summer. I do NOT however love the Beadrider for a 600 mile day. It takes putting it on, then taking it off after a while for me at least. Did not try the dead sheep, might someday...
09 WABS w. some farkles & teeth
[URL="https://www.stromtrooper.com/showthread.php?t=35638&page=3"]Strom Squadron Member #5[/URL]